Custom Embroidery vs Screen Printing: Which Should You Choose?

Two techniques dominate custom apparel branding: embroidery and screen printing. Both are versatile, both are popular, and both produce very different results. Choosing the wrong one for your design or garment can cost you quality, money, or both.

This guide breaks down exactly when to use each technique, the cost implications, durability differences, and design factors that should drive your decision.

The Fundamental Difference

Screen printing: Ink is pushed through a mesh stencil onto the fabric surface. Produces flat, vibrant colour that sits on or into the garment.

Embroidery: Thread is stitched directly into the fabric by needle. Produces a raised, textured result that's tactile and three-dimensional.

These two processes have different aesthetics, different cost structures, and different ideal use cases.

When to Choose Screen Printing

Design characteristics suited for screen printing

• Large graphic designs with fills and backgrounds
• Designs with gradients or half-tone effects (special techniques)
• Photographic or highly detailed artwork (via DTG)
• Full chest or back placement graphics
• Multiple colour designs where colour registration is important

Garment types suited for screen printing

Screen printing works on virtually any flat-surface garment: t-shirts, hoodies, sweatshirts, tote bags, caps with flat fronts.

It does NOT work well on structured surfaces, thick padding, or highly textured fabrics.

Volume economics of screen printing

The biggest factor: screen printing has setup costs (screens) and becomes more economical at higher volumes.

Per-screen setup cost: $15–$25 per colour (one-time per design)

Per-unit print cost (100 units, 3-colour print):

• Setup: $45–$75 (one-time)
• Print per unit: $1.50–$3.00
• Total print cost at 100 units: ~$2.25–$3.75 per unit

At higher volumes, the setup cost becomes negligible. At very low volumes (under 24 units), per-unit cost rises significantly.

Durability

High-quality screen printing (water-based or plastisol inks) lasts 50+ wash cycles with proper care. Discharge printing (removes fabric dye) becomes part of the fabric itself and effectively lasts the life of the garment.

Factors that affect durability:

• Ink type (plastisol > water-based for longevity, but water-based has better hand feel)
• Cure temperature during production
• Wash care (cold water, inside-out washing extends print life significantly)

When to Choose Embroidery

Design characteristics suited for embroidery

• Brand logos and wordmarks (especially at chest-left position)
• Text and monograms
• Badges and patches
• Designs where 3D texture adds to the aesthetic
• Designs meant to signal quality and premium positioning

Garment types suited for embroidery

Embroidery excels on structured items: polos, button-down shirts, hats, jackets, and heavyweight hoodies. It also works beautifully on heavy-weight tees and sweatshirts.

It's less suited for extremely thin, stretchy fabrics where the stitching pulls the fabric, or designs with very fine detail that doesn't translate to thread work.

Volume economics of embroidery

Embroidery is digitised (the design is converted to a stitch file) once, and that file is used for all future runs. Digitising cost is $20–$60 per design (one-time).

Per-unit embroidery cost (100 units, standard logo):

• Digitising: $30–$50 (one-time)
• Embroidery per unit: $2.50–$5.00 depending on stitch count
• Total at 100 units: $2.80–$5.50 per unit

Higher stitch count (larger or more complex designs) increases cost. A standard chest logo (3,000–5,000 stitches) is at the lower end; a large back design (20,000+ stitches) is significantly more expensive.

Durability

Embroidery is exceptionally durable. The thread is stitched through the fabric — it doesn't sit on top. High-quality polyester embroidery thread resists fading for the life of the garment. 100+ wash cycles with no degradation is realistic.

Direct Comparison

Factor	Screen Printing	Embroidery
Best for	Large graphics, artwork	Logos, text, badges
Minimum viable quantity	24+ (lower below this)	12+
Setup cost	$15–$25 per colour	$30–$50 per design (one-time)
Per-unit cost at 100 pcs	$1.50–$3.50	$2.50–$5.00
Durability	50–100+ washes	100+ washes (excellent)
Colour range	Unlimited	Limited by thread count (up to 15)
Detail capability	Very high (with DTG)	Medium (complex fine detail is difficult)
Perceived value	Standard	Premium
Best garments	Tees, hoodies, sweats	Polos, hats, jackets, heavyweight hoodies

The Premium Signal of Embroidery

One underappreciated factor: embroidery signals quality at point of purchase.

In a retail context, two hoodies at the same price — one with a screen-printed logo, one with an embroidered logo — create different perceptions. The embroidered piece reads as more premium. This is why luxury and premium casual brands use embroidery for their logos.

For brands positioning at $60–$120+ retail, chest embroidery on key pieces elevates the perceived value of the entire line.

Combining Both Techniques

Many brands use both on the same garment or across a collection:

• Large back graphic (screen print) + chest logo (embroidery) — High-impact visual with premium finishing
• T-shirts with screen print + Hoodies and hats with embroidery — Different price points, different techniques
• Screen print for limited edition graphics + Embroidery for core logo pieces — Creates visual hierarchy across the line

This combination approach is very common in premium streetwear and elevated casual brands.

DTG: A Third Option Worth Mentioning

DTG (Direct-to-Garment) printing bypasses screen printing limitations for small orders or complex designs:

• No setup fees — every unit is digitally printed
• Full-colour, photo-quality results
• Best for: small runs (under 24 units), photographic artwork, complex gradients
• Limitations: lower durability than screen printing (especially on dark fabrics), slightly softer colour vibrancy

DTG is excellent for sampling and testing designs before committing to screen printing minimums.

Our Decoration Services

At Potato Apparel, we handle all decoration in-house:

Screen printing: Anatol 8-colour carousels, water-based and plastisol inks, discharge, puff, metallic, and high-density techniques. No outsourcing.

Embroidery: 12-head Barudan machines, up to 15-colour thread, Wilcom digitising software. Chest logos to large back pieces.

DTG: Epson SureColor direct-to-garment printers for small runs and complex artwork.

Learn more about our full services offering or contact us to get a decoration quote for your specific design.

---

Not sure which technique is right for your design? Send us your artwork and we'll recommend the best approach based on your design, garment type, and order quantity. We quote within 24 hours.